Daddy, do fake brands come from fake branding agencies?

posted by Rob on 2010.08.12, under Brand Strategy, Design
08.12

Discovered this firm the other day and couldn’t believe my eyes when I saw their website. Landor, meet your made-in-China doppelganger.

JundoBrand homepage

Landor homepage

Is there some formal connection between these companies that justifies such blatant copycatting? Maybe, in which case this post is meaningless, and I probably owe JundoBrand an apology. But so far I haven’t found any connection (and if there is one, shouldn’t they mention it somewhere?).

I don’t think I need to explain the problem(s) I see with a branding firm simply copying a competitors’ look and feel so completely. Not to mention the support this gives to the stereotype that China is better at manufacturing copies of things than creating anything original…I mean if a branding firm can’t even try to make itself an original, we’re in pretty dire straits. I’m surprised they’re not called “Lundor,” or better yet, “Slandor.”

I’ve already contacted Landor to see if I’ve missed something here. If so, I owe you an apology, Jundo. If not, anyone know the Chinese for “cease and desist”?

http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CCIQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.landor.com%2F&ei=PbZjTJvmNYTRcdGs2M8J&usg=AFQjCNFrpeWHhZ4M2PsnIsR35Wu2zVFqWA
Share:
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg
  • QQ书签
  • del.icio.us
  • Print

comment

Highest form of flattery, mirroring, mimicking. Also how we learn to trust. Maybe they just want to make the American brand imperialists feel comfortable, recognized.

And I do think notions of “orginality” and “authenticity” are, at this point in global culture, largely moot and weary.

None of us are original. Show me a company that can effectively call itslef “original”. We and our thoughts and our ideas are all products of being immersed in a perpetual Looking Glass moshpit of mnemomics and semiotics, semantics and brands, dreaming symbolic thoughts and visuals — for centuries.

Paul van Winkle ( 2010/08/12 at 10:34 )

PvW, you’re back! Long time no blog comment. Good to hear from you, even if I’m not sure I agree with you.

Sure, you can argue “it’s all been done,” but that can only shift—not erase—the line between standing on shoulders of giants and out-and-out plagiarism. I’m actually not sure (and now curious) how website design is protected under copyright and/or trademark laws, but this is clearly a direct copy. I forgot to mention that you can email them at hello@jundobrand.com, just like Landor’s hello@landor.com (although lots of firms are doing this…is it getting old yet?).

Also, just got confirmation from Landor that they have no connection to this company.

Rob ( 2010/08/12 at 18:47 )

Rob! (Yes, you know it — enjoy and read you all the time, even if I don’t always comment.)

The direct steal of everything Landor in this – formatting, style, e-mail — is indeed disturbing and wrong, and not a good or accepted business practice (except in China).

I’ve seen so much direct theft, cut and paste, and plagiarim throughout the “creative” communications field lately that it’s difficult for me to avoid being jaded and cynical. It’s become a legitimate business pratice to immitate or emulate a competitor or customer.

And I think a lot of this intellectual de-rigoring has become pervasive in mono-cultures that are inside-out (top down), rather than customer-focused, with diverse opinions and ideas.

A group I’m fond of now is called Thrive (http://www.thrivethinking.com/ ) , a design research company that actively listens to and researches — get ready – what customers want. So design and communications follow. How novel!

Paul van Winkle ( 2010/08/13 at 11:01 )

Good post! Maybe another perspective is required to judge this case? If the brand of Landor is so generic and it’s website as well, what is there to copyright?
I respect Landor and it’s work, but the Chinese did not use the main differential aspect of the Landor identity: The Klamath (the yellow boat). Which is embedded in their history or roots. Call it what you want!

Sam ( 2011/02/13 at 10:20 )

Sam, read the last paragraph of this post by a Beijing-based IP lawyer, and I think you’ll agree that if this isn’t a case of trademark infringement, it certainly stands a chance as “unfair competition.”

Rob ( 2011/02/15 at 12:56 )

Please Leave a Reply

TrackBack URL :

pagetop

  • About the Author

    Rob Meyerson is a brand strategist currently working in Singapore.

    LinkedIn Twitter @robmeyerson FriendFeed

  • My Latest Instagram Pics

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Similar Posts

  • Recent Comments

  • Tweeting @robmeyerson

    • WTF Apple, seriously? Why is something supposedly so "intuitive" so confusing whenever it's plugged in? http://t.co/KaCKqfux
      Tuesday 07 February
    • More details on our opening for a Production Designer in Singapore. Please RT or get in touch if you know a good candi…http://t.co/PDE1c4dY
      Tuesday 07 February
    • iPhone email tells me "this email could not be sent," but doesn't tell me which email, and nothing in Outbox or Drafts? #notsimple
      Tuesday 07 February
    • @hankblank Thanks for the RT, Hank! Hope all's well in sunny OC.
      Monday 06 February
    • You know Singapore, but do you know any of its brands? http://t.co/JDsFqxgt
      Monday 06 February
  • From Google Reader

    • The Crayon-Bow, Crayola Color Chart updated
      Published: August 16, 2011
      I’m not sure how I missed this, but the designer know as Velociraptor has updated his original Crayola Color Timeline that I posted about last year, into the the new Crayon-Bow (half rainbow - half rising su...
    • Inception Chair by Vivian Chiu
      Published: August 17, 2011
      Source: Design Milk
      I missed this Inception Chair by Vivian Chiu because it was being exhibited in Noho during ICFF. It was a big regret of mine being unable to get to Noho to check out the great installations.The Inception Chair...
    • Tattly
      Published: July 17, 2011
      Source: Design Milk
      My friend Tina (AKA Swissmiss) has launched Tattly, a new online store for — get this — designy temporary tattoos! Yes, now you can wear your love of design right on your sleeve. Why get a permanent MOM whe...
    • See all shared items
    • Plugin by C. Murray Consulting
  • Alltop – Top Branding News